Contesting a will in New Zealand: understanding the process
28 September 2025

When someone passes away, their will is meant to provide clear instructions about how their estate should be managed and distributed. For most families, it offers a sense of direction during a time of grief. But sometimes, questions arise, and a will may be contested.

 

Contesting a will isn’t common, but when it does happen, it can be emotionally and legally complex. At Willis Legal, we’re here to help you understand what’s involved, and to support you through the process with care, clarity, and professionalism.

 

Why might a will be contested?

 

A will can only be challenged on specific legal grounds. Examples include:


  • Family Protection Act claims - where close family members feel they haven’t been properly provided for in the will.
  • Property (Relationships) Act claims - where a surviving partner may be entitled to a share of relationship property.
  • Concerns about validity - for example, if the will wasn’t signed or witnessed correctly, or if the person lacked mental capacity when they made it.
  • Undue influence - where someone may have unfairly pressured the will-maker.

 

It’s important to note that not everyone can contest a will. The law limits this right to certain people, usually spouses, children, or dependents. If you’re unsure whether you’re eligible to make a claim, seeking early legal advice is key.

 

What does the process involve?

 

If someone believes they have grounds to contest a will, the process typically includes:


  • Obtaining a copy of the will and the assets and liabilities of the estate.
  • Negotiation and mediation - many disputes are resolved through negotiation or mediation, without the need for a full court hearing.
  • Filing a claim in court - this must be done within a set timeframe, usually within 6-12 months of probate being granted.
  • Court involvement - the High Court or Family Court will consider the claim and review supporting evidence, which may include medical records, witness statements, or details of family circumstances.
  • Court decision - if no agreement is reached, the Court will make a decision about whether the will should be changed or upheld.

 

Every case is different, and the Court will look closely at the individual circumstances. The law aims to balance the wishes of the person who made the will with fairness to those left behind.

 

Things to keep in mind

 

Contesting a will can be stressful, and it may affect family relationships. Timeframes are strict, and the process can be emotionally charged. It is important to seek legal advice early - not just to understand your rights and the process involved, but to help you navigate the situation with clarity and confidence.

 

At Willis Legal, we take a people-first approach. We understand that behind every legal issue is a family, a story, and a need for support. Whether you’re considering a claim or responding to one, we’ll walk alongside you: explaining your options, helping you weigh the risks, and working toward a resolution that respects both the law and the people involved.

 

How we can help

 

Our team has extensive experience in estate matters, including contested wills. We’ll listen carefully, explain things in plain language, and tailor our advice to your situation. We’re here to help you move forward constructively, with empathy, expertise, and a focus on what matters most.


If you have questions about a will or estate, or you’re unsure where to start, get in touch with us. We’re here to help.

Join our Newsletter

Stay tuned

Contact Us

3 August 2026
1. Myth: “The Property Relationships Act applies after 2 years!” - Wrong Generally, the time period for a relationship to become what is known as a qualifying relationship under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 is 3 years from the commencement of the relationship. This time period can be shorter if there is a child in the relationship or the applicant has made a substantial contribution to the relationship. The 2 year period is the period a married couple must be separated before the marriage can be dissolved (i.e. divorced). 2. Myth: “It’s my property – I can leave it to whomever I want!” Wrong (sort of) This statement highlights the tension between what lawyers refer to as “testamentary freedom” that a Will-maker has and rights certain persons have under various statutes and law. While it is true that a Will-maker can do what they want with their property, this is not absolute. A Court can order a different distribution where a Will-maker fails in what is known as their “moral duty” to make “proper maintenance and support” for family members. In addition partners have rights under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976, and the Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949 can assist persons to whom the Will-maker has made promises to provide for them in return for work or services done in the Will-maker’s lifetime. The rules of equity may also affect the Will-maker’s testamentary freedom. 3. Myth: “I’ve been in a relationship for 30 years so surely I can make decisions for my partner who has lost mental capacity!” – Wrong Despite the length of a relationship (marriage/de facto/civil union) if one of the partners loses mental capacity the other partner has no right to make decisions for their incapacitated partner in relation to their property and/or their personal care and welfare, unless the incapacitated partner has completed Enduring Powers of Attorney. If the incapacitated partner has not completed Enduring Powers of Attorney applications to the Family Court will need to be made for the appointment of a Property Manager (or Administrator if there are not significant assets) and a Welfare Guardian. 4. Myth: “I can buy/sell a house without a lawyer involved” – Wrong (sort of) In theory, a layperson can buy or sell a home without the involvement of a lawyer but (and it is a big but) it would be very difficult to do so (not to mention the risk of doing so). If bank lending is involved, the bank will insist on the involvement of a lawyer to act on its behalf and may even decline to lend if a buyer is not legally represented. Even if the bank was prepared to lend it is likely it and its lawyers would impose so many conditions and requirements (in order to protect the bank’s position) that it may be practically too difficult for a buyer act for themselves. Furthermore, with the land register now being predominantly electronic, relying on lawyers with the requisite certifications, it will be difficult for a non-licenced person to transact the registrations. Again, in theory, these can be done manually in paper form but the formalities involved in doing so is likely to make it practically difficult (if not impossible) for a buyer or seller to do so. This is general information about the current law, not advice on a specific matter. Article by: Kevin Callinicos
2 August 2026
After 135 years in Hawke's Bay, the community is just part of how the Willis Legal works. With offices in Napier and Hastings, we are never far away from helping you with any legal matter.
29 July 2026
Buying your first home? We've helped hundreds of people through this exact process. Our free First Home Buyers' Guide covers everything you wish you knew before you started.
Show More