The Benefits and Challenges of Trusts
13 April 2025

How an Independent Professional Trustee Could be of Assistance

Trusts have long been a popular tool for managing and protecting assets. They offer various benefits, especially for those who own their own business or want to ensure their assets are protected. However, there are also some drawbacks to consider. Here, we'll explore both the benefits and the cons of setting up a trust, helping you decide if it's the right option for you. 

 

Benefits of Trusts 

  1. Asset protection: Trusts are particularly beneficial for business owners, as they protect personal assets from business risks and creditors. By placing assets in a trust, you can shield them from being drawn down to pay personal debts or from relationship property claims. This ensures that your personal wealth remains secure, even if your business faces financial challenges. 
  2. Tax efficiency: Depending on your situation, trusts can offer tax efficiencies. However, it's essential to speak with an accountant to understand how a trust can impact your tax obligations. A well-structured trust can help minimise tax liabilities and maximise the benefits for your beneficiaries. 
  3. Estate planning: Trusts play a crucial role in estate planning. They ensure that your assets are distributed according to your wishes after your passing. However, it's essential to consider if other instruments like wills, enduring powers of attorney (EPOAs), or specific ownership structures might be better suited for your needs. 
  4. Serving certain family dynamics: Trusts can be tailored to serve specific family dynamics, ensuring that assets are retained for family members who may need them the most. This includes providing for those with disabilities, rest home care, or hospital care. A trust can help ensure that your loved ones are cared for, even if you are no longer around. 


Cons of Trusts 

  1. Loss of control of assets: When you set up a trust, the assets are no longer considered your personal assets. They belong to the trust, and the trustees have decision-making control over them. This means you need consensus decision-making from all trustees, and the assets are governed according to the powers outlined in the trust deed. 
  2. Ongoing administration and costs: Trusts require ongoing administration, including maintaining records, fulfilling disclosure obligations, filing tax returns, and complying with legal requirements. This can be time-consuming and costly, which might be a downside unless there is a good reason for having a trust. 
  3. Tax implications: While trusts can offer tax efficiencies, they also come with tax implications. It's essential to understand these implications and seek professional advice to ensure compliance with tax laws and regulations. 
  4. Legal challenges: If a trust is not administered properly, it can face legal challenges. This can result in disputes among beneficiaries or questions about the validity of the trust. Proper administration and adherence to legal obligations are crucial to avoid such issues. 


Independent Professional Trustees  

Appointing an independent professional trustee such as accountants or lawyers (including one of Willis Legal’s Trustee Companies) for your Trust can offer several desirable benefits.


Such benefits include: 

  1. Transparency and Independence: Appointing an independent trustee can ensure that the trust’s assets are managed, and decisions affecting assets are made, in a totally independent manner. This gives the Trust integrity and can provide beneficiaries with peace of mind. This can be particularly important when family or business dynamics are complex or strained. Independent trustees can also help to avoid or negate any perception of a ‘sham trust’. 
  2. Stability over time: Private trustees might lose their ability, willingness or capacity to act as trustee over the life of the Trust. However, professional trustee companies provide longevity, consistency and stability. The costs of retiring trustees unable or unwilling to act and appointing new trustees can be reduced, particularly over time. 
  3. Knowledge and expertise: Professional trustees hold the up-to-date and best practice information on New Zealand Trust legislation. This knowledge and expertise encourages strong compliance with the Trusts Act 2019 as well as proper administration and record-keeping.  The knowledge and advice gained from having a professional trustee included can assist other trustees with decision-making regarding the trust’s assets and administration. 


Overall considerations 

When deciding whether to create a new trust, it's essential to have a specific and good reason. One of the benefits listed above should outweigh the cons. It's also crucial to speak with a lawyer to assess if a trust is the right vehicle to achieve your objectives and tailor it to your individual circumstances. For example, transferring assets into a trust could potentially affect your eligibility for residential care subsidies. Therefore, professional advice is vital before making any decisions in relation to trusts. 


We encourage settlors (creating a new Trust) or continuing trustees who are appointing any new Trustees, to consider whether an independent professional trustee might be beneficial. As outlined above, there can be significant advantages to having an independent professional trustee included.


Willis Legal provides its own independent professional trustee service, ask about it today.


If you believe that creating a Trust might be of benefit to you, your family or business and/or if you are interested in including an independent professional trustee – please do not hesitate to contact one of our friendly staff and we would be happy to discuss this with you in further detail.   

Join our Newsletter

Stay tuned

Contact Us

3 August 2026
1. Myth: “The Property Relationships Act applies after 2 years!” - Wrong Generally, the time period for a relationship to become what is known as a qualifying relationship under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 is 3 years from the commencement of the relationship. This time period can be shorter if there is a child in the relationship or the applicant has made a substantial contribution to the relationship. The 2 year period is the period a married couple must be separated before the marriage can be dissolved (i.e. divorced). 2. Myth: “It’s my property – I can leave it to whomever I want!” Wrong (sort of) This statement highlights the tension between what lawyers refer to as “testamentary freedom” that a Will-maker has and rights certain persons have under various statutes and law. While it is true that a Will-maker can do what they want with their property, this is not absolute. A Court can order a different distribution where a Will-maker fails in what is known as their “moral duty” to make “proper maintenance and support” for family members. In addition partners have rights under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976, and the Law Reform (Testamentary Promises) Act 1949 can assist persons to whom the Will-maker has made promises to provide for them in return for work or services done in the Will-maker’s lifetime. The rules of equity may also affect the Will-maker’s testamentary freedom. 3. Myth: “I’ve been in a relationship for 30 years so surely I can make decisions for my partner who has lost mental capacity!” – Wrong Despite the length of a relationship (marriage/de facto/civil union) if one of the partners loses mental capacity the other partner has no right to make decisions for their incapacitated partner in relation to their property and/or their personal care and welfare, unless the incapacitated partner has completed Enduring Powers of Attorney. If the incapacitated partner has not completed Enduring Powers of Attorney applications to the Family Court will need to be made for the appointment of a Property Manager (or Administrator if there are not significant assets) and a Welfare Guardian. 4. Myth: “I can buy/sell a house without a lawyer involved” – Wrong (sort of) In theory, a layperson can buy or sell a home without the involvement of a lawyer but (and it is a big but) it would be very difficult to do so (not to mention the risk of doing so). If bank lending is involved, the bank will insist on the involvement of a lawyer to act on its behalf and may even decline to lend if a buyer is not legally represented. Even if the bank was prepared to lend it is likely it and its lawyers would impose so many conditions and requirements (in order to protect the bank’s position) that it may be practically too difficult for a buyer act for themselves. Furthermore, with the land register now being predominantly electronic, relying on lawyers with the requisite certifications, it will be difficult for a non-licenced person to transact the registrations. Again, in theory, these can be done manually in paper form but the formalities involved in doing so is likely to make it practically difficult (if not impossible) for a buyer or seller to do so. This is general information about the current law, not advice on a specific matter. Article by: Kevin Callinicos
2 August 2026
After 135 years in Hawke's Bay, the community is just part of how the Willis Legal works. With offices in Napier and Hastings, we are never far away from helping you with any legal matter.
29 July 2026
Buying your first home? We've helped hundreds of people through this exact process. Our free First Home Buyers' Guide covers everything you wish you knew before you started.
Show More